ENGL 302
Section H31, Spring 2008
TR 12-1:15
Innovation Hall 328
Course Syllabus
ENGL 302 section H31 |
Dr. Kenneth C. Thompson |
TR 12-1:15 Innovation Hall 328 |
Office Hours: TR 2:00-3:00 and by appointment Office: Enterprise 345 Office Phone: 703-993-2781 Email: kthomps4 gmu.edu |
Engl302 Blog:
http://302h31s08.wordpress.com |
Course Web Page: http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/ |
REQUIRED TEXTS:
Diana Hacker, A Pocket Style Manual. Bedford/St.Martin's. Paper (spiral bound)
Gregory Black, Hollywood Censored: Morality Codes, Catholics, and the Movies. Cambridge UP. Paper
Minow and Lemay, Abandoned in the Wasteland: Children, Television, & the First Amendment. Hill and Wang. Paper
E-TEXTS AND RESOURCES:
PURPOSE OF THIS CLASS: The course will provide you with an opportunity to improve your writing and develop your research skills while exploring several recurring issues connected with censorship, film, and the media. We will look at the emergence of new communications technologies like the internet and place them in historical perspective by studying anxieties generated by earlier forms of literature and entertainment. We will pay particular attention to the constitutional issues raised by censorship; you will have the chance to develop your own ideas while writing papers on film censorship, the regulation of children's television, and cyberspace. You have the option of writing your final research paper on one of these topics. I will comment extensively on your writing over the course of the semester and I will expect your final research paper to demonstrate improvement in the areas you need to work on. This paper should be 10-14 pages (double spaced) and should make significant use of 10 sources.
DUAL SUBMISSION OPTION FOR FINAL RESEARCH PAPER: Instead of writing your final research paper on one of the topics we have covered, you may dual submit a research paper from another course you are currently taking in your major. If you take advantage of this option, you must meet the requirements of both classes and you will receive a separate grade for the paper in 302 and the other course. The paper should be at least 10 pages (double spaced) and should make significant use of 10 sources.
REQUIREMENTS: 1) Regular attendance. Participation in all class activities including workshops, group projects, and individual presentations. 2) Completion of all assigned reading. 3) On-time completion of all written work including paper editing sheets, quizzes, papers, bibliographies, and proposals. After three late assignments, each succeeding late project will be lowered half a grade. I will accept no assignments that are over one week late. All assignments are due at the beginning of class on the day indicated on the syllabus.
NOTE ON PLAGIARISM: The English Department defines plagiarism as "using the exact words, opinions, or factual information from another source without giving that source credit. Writers give credit through the use of accepted documentation styles, such as parenthetical citation, footnotes, or end notes; a simple listing of books, articles, and websites is not sufficient. Plagiarism is the equivalent of intellectual robbery and cannot be tolerated in an academic setting." I will not tolerate plagiarism in my classes and will report incidents to the appropriate authorities.
GRADING:
PAPERS: 33%
FINAL PAPER AND RESEARCH PROJECT: 33%
PARTICIPATION AND GROUP WORK: 33%
SCHEDULE (SUBJECT TO REVISION)
DATE | ENGL 302 (section H31) |
---|---|
Tue Jan 22 | Introduction to the course;
Information Sheet
and blog set up. Also, go to
http://mail.gmu.edu and set up mail
forwarding if you do not check your GMU email several times a week. I
will also help you add my email addresses to your safe list so messages
about the class will not be blocked by GMU's
spam filter.
Introduce yourself to the class on the blog at http://302h31s08.wordpress.com/ The first time you go to the site you will need to register on WordPress unless you already have an account. Use the Sign Up Now Button at the top of the wordpress.com page. Enter your GMU user name and email address and write down your password (or use one you will remember). Leave Gimme a blog unchecked. I will use your GMU email address to give you write privileges on the blog. Because this may take a while, you may want to begin your writing using an HTML editor or Word (saving the file as a web page ). Once you are fully have registered, you should see a New Post link at the top of the page (if you don't see it try using Firefox rather than IE). Give your post a title like "Introduction," and enter the text of your post in the box under Post. Once I have given you authorship privileges on the blog, you should see a check box with your name under People at the top right of the Write page (its one of the "categories." Also check Introductions before you click on Publish. If you finish your introduction before other students, read the first page on Scarface at filmsite.org site, up to the plot summary, section 1. Also familiarize yourself with the Internet Movie Database by looking up Scarface (1932; directed by Howard Hawks, 93 minutes) at http://imdb.com/. You should also study the text added at the behest of the Hays' Office (the film industry censorship group) at: http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/stills/scarface/scar-text.htm. (In the future, if you forget the user name and password required to view such files, email me). If there is time, we will begin work on the initial project in the class, a guided research paper on film censorship and the production history of Scarface (1932; directed by Howard Hawks, 93 minutes), by watching the beginning of the film in class. We will continue the film next class, at which time you will post your reactions to the film on the class blog. |
Thur Jan 24 |
We will watch about 25 min of Scarface in class. Before class, study the text added at the behest of the Hays' Office, available at: http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/stills/scarface/scar-text.htm. We will discuss what the text adds to the film. If you have forgotten the user name and password required to view the files, email me. After class, study the list of the film's characters on the Internet Movie Database. Go to http://imdb.com/ and look up Scarface (1932) and then Post to the Blog a 250 words response detailing your reactions to the film. Include your view Tony Camonte's character and your thoughts on whether the film glorifies violence and gangsters. Also read the first page on Scarface at filmsite.org site, up to the plot summary, section 1. |
Tue Jan 29 | Read Gregory Black, Hollywood Censored, pp. 107-111 (up to discussion of Little Caesar), 121-132 (up to discussion of prison films). Scarface, continued, in class. |
Thur Jan 31 | Scarface, continued, in class. If there is time, we will study the two filmed endings after we discuss how Scarface's action sequences are filmed as opposed to the style used in shooting the Chief's and Publisher's condemnations of gangsters. If we don't finish the film in class today, we will do so next Tues. |
Tue Feb 5 |
Before class, write a 2-4 page paper (typed and double spaced). Describe and analyze of two or more changes made in the movie at the behest of the Hay's Office. Make sure your review Black, pp. 125-132, before writing your account. You will exchange papers in class and fill out a paper editing sheet. After we have watched the alternate endings of the film in class, you will post to the blog several paragraphs on the three endings of Scarface (the script, the 'coward' runs, and the hanging). Take a position on: 1) whether the ending in the original script, which was never filmed, glorified Camonte; and 2) whether it makes a difference for our view of Camonte and the government whether he is killed as he runs from his hideout (the first ending filmed and the one we see today) or is tried and punished by government officials. You can review part of Scarface's 3rd ending at: http://classweb.gmu.edu/kthomps4/video/scar-sm.mov. This is the version most viewers saw at the time but is only available now in a DVD the library doesn't own, so its crucial you not miss class on Feb 5th. If you don't have time to post your entry to the blog in class, do so before we meet Thurs. Feb 6th--Last day to drop with no tuition liability and last day to add classes |
Thur Feb 7 |
Before class, read Amendment I of the Bill of Rights and Section 12 of The Virginia Declaration of Rights (the Declaration was written by George Mason). During class, you will post to the blog at least two paragraphs on: 1) what you learned from the reading in Black about why gangster movies upset critics and citizen groups; and 2) Whether you think censorship of the kind we see in the production history of Scarface is consistent with democratic principles. If you don't have time to post your entry to the blog in class, do so by Friday at midnight. If you
finish the in-class writing early, read Diana Hacker on pronoun reference,
pp. 39-40, and start working through the exercises on pronoun reference
(12-4 through 12-6) at |
Tue Feb 12 |
Read Gregory Black, Hollywood Censored, pp. 3-46 (restricting
entertainment and the Hays office); 151-154 (Payne study), and 302-308
(Lord-Quigley proposal).
Quiz
on Block v. Chicago (1909), The National Board of Review,
Mutual Film Company v. The Industrial Commission of Ohio, and the
early days of the Hays Office.
After the quiz, I will divide the class into four or five groups. Each group will read one section of the Lord-Quigley code and summarize its larger and subsidiary points in a group report on the blog after first posting individual responses. In your groups, discuss you individual responses and postings on particular components of the assignment. Include in group report any disagreements you had on the value of the code and any thoughts you had on its application to Scarface. This exercise requires you to place Lord and Quigley's individual points in larger structure or set of assumptions you distill from the details of the code. You can use bullets or an outline for the subsidiary points. I will divide up the class as follows:
|
Thur Feb 14 |
Group reports and individual responses, continued. Discuss your group's response to the proposal including any disagreements you had on the value of the code and any thoughts you had on its application to Scarface. This exercise requires you to place Lord and Quigley's individual points in larger structure or set of assumptions you distill from the details of the code. You can use bullets or an outline for the subsidiary points. Both individual responses and group reports should be complete and posted on the blog by Saturday at midnight if you don't finish your work in class. I will divide up the class as follows:
After you complete your group reports, finish the exercises on pronoun reference (12-4 through 12-6) at http://dianahacker.com/pocket/gm_menu.asp |
Tue Feb 19 |
Review of group presentations on the Lord and Quigley code. Everyone should carefully read the other blogs on the Lord and Quigley draft of the code as well as your own. Then talk with the other members in your group about the other sites. Go over:
After you have looked at each group's report and discussed the points above, post at least one comment on each group report with your questions and comments. You can divide up the work but make sure you cover the points above in comments on each blog. In your comments, make sure to include your group number and the names of those who participated. Review of MLA, APA, and Chicago documentation styles, particularly how to use the drop-down menus on Hacker's online site. If there is time, you will work on the paper due next Wed and I will talk with you individually about your plans. |
Thur Feb 21 |
Read the Supreme Court's
Mutual Film Company v. The Industrial Commission of Ohio decision
from 1915 and Black's account on pp. 15-18. We will go over the case in
detail in class, discussing not only the content of the decision but the
writing as well. Blog
posting summarizing the issues in the case, the arguments on both sides,
and the decision--as well as your response to reading the case--is due
by Wed at midnight.
Review of MLA, APA, and Chicago documentation styles, particularly how to use the drop-down menus on Hacker's online site. If there is time, you will work on the paper due Feb 28th and I will talk with you individually about your plans. Feb 23rd--Last day to drop classes |
Tue Feb 26 |
We will watch the 1999 PBS Culture Shock documentary Hollywood Censored: Movies, Morality, and the Hollywood Production Code. Post to the blog a paragraph on David Denby's distinction between representational complexity and teaching unambiguous moral lessons. |
Thur Feb 28 |
Write a 4-6 page paper (typed and double spaced) in which you take a
position on whether Scarface as originally conceived and/or filmed
(in the script and/or the early shootings) was a dangerous film. Discuss at
least two changes made to the movie in response to the censors and explain
why you think the alterations improve or harm the film. Also indicate
whether these changes reflect the concerns seen in the Hays' Code. Include
a discussion of the relevant background material covered in Black and a
detailed analysis of individual scenes (from the film and scripts) as you
develop and support your thesis. As we discussed in class, a thesis is more
than a topic; it's a position you take on an issue or the answer you give to
a question you have asked.
You will exchange papers in class and fill out the following paper editing sheet: http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/p-edit_scar2.doc. Those who miss class will have to exchange their papers with someone in the class before I can evaluate it. If there is time, we will watch more of the documentary Hollywood Censored. |
Tue Mar 4 |
You will work on a plan and a new/revised introductory paragraph for the revised guided research paper due March 18th. You will use the following sheet today (Tue) to guide group discussion of your plans: http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/pap3-plan.doc Also see the
intro paragraph for the paper on the class blog (10-Scarface sample paper).
Read the first few paragraphs and leave a comment on how effective you think
the intro is. (If the blog is offline, see the
intro paragraphs at Since several of you may have written abstractly--rather than in specific terms--about who did what, when, and why in your recent papers on censoring Scarface, we will do grammar and style exercises on wordiness & active and passive verbs from Diana Hacker's site at http://dianahacker.com/pocket/ |
Thur Mar 6 |
We will watch D.W. Griffith's 1912 film, The Musketeers of Pig Alley, (18 min.) often considered the first gangster feature. We may also look at a photograph from 1888 by Jacob Riis, Bandit's Roost (Scan courtesy of Masters of Photography). See the Masters of Photography site for images and commentary on Riis, whose work is often seen as a precursor of the approach Griffith took to visualizing the world of gangsters. |
Tue Mar 11 | SPRING BREAK March 10-16th |
Thur Mar 13 | SPRING BREAK March 10-16th |
Tue Mar 18 |
Final
guided research paper due at the beginning of class: This will
be the last paper in the guided research sequence. It should be 6
pages, typed and double spaced. You can write more, if the additional
pages advance your position and do not repeat or wander from you main
point. Include a works cited page/list of references and indicate
whether you are following MLA, APA or Chicago (see Hacker's online
documentation guide at
http://www.bedfordstmartins.com/hacker/resdoc/). Choose one of the
following options:
See the longer paper assignment sheet at: http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/paper3.htm You will exchange papers in class and fill out the following paper editing sheet: http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/p-edit-scarwest3.htm. If there is time, we will begin our in-class viewing and discussion of the PBS documentary on children's television, Does TV Kill, and go over the listing of research sources and writing guides put together by GMU's specialist librarians at: http://library.gmu.edu/resources/web.html. During the next few classes, I will demonstrate how to use the CQ Researcher for topic searches and the LexisNexis database for newspapers and periodicals. At that point, we will do the following exercises: 1) Use LexisNexis to find the text of the 1909 Illinois Supreme Court decision in Block v. Chicago; 2) Use CQ Researcher to find an overview article on Children's Television from Aug 15th, 1997; and 3) find articles and books by at least four of the researchers mentioned in Does TV Kill, trying out each of the databases we have covered as well as others you think might be useful based on your study of the research sources and writing guides put together by GMU's specialist librarians at: http://library.gmu.edu/resources/web.html. |
Thur Mar 20 |
We selections from the Frontline documentary, Does TV Kill. A transcript is available at: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/programs/transcripts/1307.html. If there is time, we will review the LexisNexis and CQ Researcher databases, go over ProQuest and Expanded Academic ASAP. At that point, you will practice using them by looking up the researchers cited in the Frontline documentary. Remember to save your list of the research covered in the documentary. March 21st Midterm grades due; incomplete work from the fall due to instructor; last day to withdraw |
Tue Mar 25 | Read Minow and Lamay, Abandoned in the Wasteland, pp.3-44, 105-131. In-class discussion of Minow and Lamay's argument and rhetorical strategies. Think about whether there is a continuous argument tying the sections you read together. Look in particular at what Minow says about the phrases "vast wasteland" and "public interest" on pp. 3-4 and the quotation from Lippmann on pp. 115-116. In addition to discussing the book's position on children's television and the 1st Amendment, we will consider its use rhetorical strategies like repetition (pp. 8-9, 108), review Diana Hacker on balancing parallel ideas (pp. 6-7), and do the exercises on parallelism at http://dianahacker.com/pocket/ |
Thur Mar 27 |
Review Minow and Lamay's account of Supreme Court cases (pp. 119-133) and
think about whether they are making a larger point. You will post your
thoughts on this issue to the blog
at the beginning of the class. Also review pp. 27-33 and come to class
prepared to talk about how the authors use research in developing their
argument. We will continue our examination of the potential advantages
and risks of rhetorical strategies the authors use by going over the
exaggerated scenario in the introduction to the first chapter (pp. 17-18).
We will also look at how this section invokes scholarly authorities and how
its exaggerated scenario becomes a unifying motif a few pages later (pp.
24-25).
As part of our continuing exploration of writing and audience, we will listen to part of Minow's address to the National Association of Broadcasters in 1961. If there is time, we will study the Parent's Television Council and Morality in Media sites, look up these organizations in the Associations Unlimited database, study Diana Hacker on choppy sentences (pp. 16-17), and do some exercises on her website at http://dianahacker.com/pocket/ Mar 31--Incomplete grade changes fall 04 due to Registrar |
Tue Apr 1 | We will review the LexisNexis and
CQ
Researcher databases, go over
ProQuest and
Expanded Academic ASAP.
You will practice using them by completing the following exercises: 1)
Use LexisNexis to find the text of the 1909 Illinois Supreme Court decision
in Block v. Chicago; 2) Use CQ Researcher to find an overview
article on Children's Television from Aug 15th, 1997; and 3) find
articles and books by at least four of the researchers mentioned in Does
TV Kill, trying out each of the databases we have covered as well as
others you think might be useful based on your study of the research sources
and writing guides put together by GMU's specialist librarians at:
http://library.gmu.edu/resources/web.html. If there is time, we will watch more of the Frontline documentary, Does TV Kill. A transcript is available at: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/programs/transcripts/1307.html. If you are considering writing on the censorship of more recent technologies of art, entertainment and communication, look at the Sex, Laws and Cyberspace web page, available at: http://www.spectacle.org/freespch/. |
Thur Apr 3 |
Preliminary plan, outline, and bibliography for you final
research paper due at beginning of class
(intro paragraph optional). By Fri at 5pm, post to the
blog a brief account of your plan.
In-class review of LexisNexis, CQ Researcher, ProQuest, and Expanded Academic ASAP databases. You can find all the library databases at http://furbo.gmu.edu/dbwiz/SPT--BrowseResources.php (scroll to the bottom of the page for an alphabetical list). Then find three full text peer reviewed scholarly articles on one of the following subjects: film censorship in the 1930, children's television and the 1st Amendment, regulating cyberspace, or another of the topics for the final research paper. If you want, post information about any articles you have found that might be relevant to your final paper on the blog. |
Tue Apr 8 |
We will talk about the Biology Department's writing guide at:
http://classweb.gmu.edu/WAC/Biology/ and the Writing Across the Curriculum writing guide page at: http://wac.gmu.edu/guides/guides.html We will watch about an hour of a documentary on film censorship in the 30's titled Thou Shalt Not: Sex, Sin and Censorship in Pre-Code Hollywood. It’s from the Forbidden Hollywood Collection DVD vol. 2. The library only has vol 1, not this volume, but it is shown on Turner Classic Movies from time to time. |
Thur Apr 10 | Paper workshop |
Tue Apr 15 |
Revised plan,
outline, bibliography and intro for you final
research paper due at beginning of class.
Update your plan on the blog before class and post an account of your
conversation with class members about your plan at the end of class.
We will discuss the introductory
paragraphs at |
Thur Apr 17 |
We will do exercises in class on misplaced and dangling modifiers from the Diana Hacker site for A Pocket Style Manual at http://dianahacker.com/pocket/ Before class, read Hacker on misplaced modifiers (pp. 13-15); variety (pp. 16-18); and commas after intro word groups (pp. 64-5). See http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/intro-scar4.doc for introductory paragraphs we will go over in class if there is time. |
Tue Apr 22 | Paper workshop #1:
you will have about 45 minutes to work on your final papers. I will
meet with you individually while you work.
Before class, read Hacker on finding a voice (pp. 18-22). Her glossary of usage (pp. 210-220) will be a useful resource as you revise your paper. We will go over Hacker on fragments and run-on sentences (pp. 48-55) and do some of the exercises from the Diana Hacker site for A Pocket Style Manual at http://dianahacker.com/pocket/ We will also go over the sections in Hacker's handbook on restrictive and non-restrictive clauses (p. 66) and her Checklist for Global Revisions (p. 248). If there is time, we will go over the sentences found at http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/sentences2.htm |
Thur Apr 24 | Paper workshop #2: you are responsible for bringing to class two copies of your final paper draft. You will exchange drafts of the paper with another member of the class and fill out a paper editing sheet. Your draft should be at least 4 pages (longer if you are revising an earlier paper). The paper editing sheet is available at http://mason.gmu.edu/~kthomps4/302-H31-s08/finalpaper-edit.doc Each of you should explain to a fellow student what you are writing on, what your argument will be, what sources you have found, and the problems you are having. Ask constructive questions and exchange information and leads you have found helpful. Post an account of your conversation to the blog after class. |
Tue Apr 29 | No class--extended office hours for paper conferences 2-530pm (Enterprise 345; 993-2781). If you want an extension till Fri May 9th, you will need to bring a substantial draft for me to look over either today or Thurs. If you want, you can email me your draft before your meeting. |
Thur May 1 |
Today is the last meeting of the class. Make sure you arrive on time
so you can do course evaluations. After that, I will continue to meet
with students individually to go over drafts with those who want an
extension till Fri May 9th. Remember that the final paper needs to be in a folder with the
most recent draft (with comments and/or editing sheets), the
paragraph structure sheet, your original paper plan, and an account of what you changed as you
worked on your project. Also indicate which citation format you used (APA,
MLA, Chicago or one of the Sciences listed on the
Hacker documentation site) May 5th--Last day of classes; exam period--May 8th-16th |
Fri May 9 |
Final paper due in my box (to the left of Enterprise 345) by 5pm if you brought a substantial draft to class last week |