Comment
Key |
||||||||
C |
Violates something on the Conventions for Writing in the Humanities | |||||||
E |
Violates something on the List of Incredibly Annoying Errors | |||||||
W |
Violates something on the Advice on Cutting Words | |||||||
Q |
Violates something on the Quotations and Citations Guidelines | |||||||
pgh |
Paragraph (if no other explanation, break paragraph here) | |||||||
fr |
Sentence fragment | |||||||
Z | comma splice or other run-on sentence; break here | |||||||
sv |
Subject-verb
conflict |
|||||||
vf |
Verb
form error |
|||||||
a/a |
Adjective/adverb confusion | |||||||
ps |
Other part of speech confusion | |||||||
ts |
Inappropriate or unnecessary verb tense shift | |||||||
ns |
Number shift, meaning an inappropriate change from singular to plural or the reverse | |||||||
ant |
No (or unclear or mismatched) antecedent for a pronoun | |||||||
pr |
Pronoun shift or incorrect pronoun use not involving an antecedent | |||||||
pp |
Apostrophe error (which is usually a matter of confusing plurals and possessives) | |||||||
dp |
Dangling participle | |||||||
mm | Misplaced modifier or modifying phrase | |||||||
syn | Confusing or awkward syntax (the arrangement of the parts of a sentence) that is not a dp or mm | |||||||
prp |
Poor choice of preposition | |||||||
pv |
Unnecessary or excesssive passive voice | |||||||
wdy |
Other wordy construction (not on the Advice on Cutting Words) | |||||||
tr |
Incorrect or no transition | |||||||
wc |
Poor word choice or imprecise vocabulary | |||||||
?? |
Confusing (one ? means you need a question mark there) | |||||||
rpt |
Repetitious, meaning that you have made this point already | |||||||
rdt |
Redundant, meaning that this particular phrasing is repetitive | |||||||
sp |
Misspelled word (but not on the List of Incredibly Annoying Errors) | |||||||
cp |
Capitalization problem (should be capitalized if it’s not, shouldn’t be if it is) | |||||||
cite |
Failure to cite source | |||||||
SoA | Scale of Abstraction problem (moving from a broad point to a narrow one too quickly, or the reverse) | |||||||
argh! |
General
comment meaning “I can’t believe you did this again!”
(The length of the word and number of exclamation points indicates my
level of frustration: “argh!” is bad enough, but “aaaarrrrgggghhhhhhhh!!!!”
is worse.) |
|||||||
|